High Court throws out Iswaran's bid to get prosecution to hand over statements of all its witnesses

8 months ago 84

SINGAPORE: A High Court judge on Friday (Jul 19) tossed out a bid by former transport minister S Iswaran to compel the prosecution to hand over statements of all its witnesses.

Iswaran's lawyers, led by Senior Counsel Davinder Singh, had already lost their first attempt in a June hearing not open to the public, and this was their second try in a criminal revision heard on Jul 5.

Justice Vincent Hoong said there was nothing in the wording of the Criminal Procedure Code to support the defence's argument that the prosecution is required to disclose all conditioned statements of its witnesses or draft statements of witnesses who do not want to sign off on conditioned statements.

Justice Hoong also rejected the defence's argument that there has been an abuse of process or serious injustice on the prosecution's part.

The development comes about a month before Iswaran is set to go on trial in the High Court for his criminal charges. CNA understands his trial begins on Aug 13.

Corruption cases are usually heard in the State Courts, but the prosecution had successfully applied for this case to be heard in the High Court in March.

The 62-year-old Singaporean faces a total of 35 charges comprising 32 counts of obtaining valuables as a public servant, two counts of corruption and one of obstructing justice.

These relate to his interactions with property tycoon Ong Beng Seng and Mr Lum Kok Seng, the managing director of Singapore-listed Lum Chang Holdings.

Neither Mr Ong nor Mr Lum have been charged, with the Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC) previously saying that they would take a decision over the investigations against both men after Iswaran's case has been completed.

In the criminal revision hearing, Mr Singh had asked the prosecution to make available all conditioned statements - signed written statements used as evidence in a court case - to the defence.

If not, he asked for "draft" statements or all written statements from the prosecution witnesses.

He alleged that his client was ...

Read Entire Article